microsoft ghosted after verbal offer


Ghosted after 7 interviews at Morgan Stanley. No emails, texts or phone calls are initiated to explain to the other party whats going on. Maybe one more follow up email wouldn't hurt, but you've probably been ghosted. Perhaps most important, maintain frequent communication with the candidate during the period between offer acceptance (whether verbal or written) and day one. I sent them a follow-up email a couple days back, but haven't heard back. Comments ( 23) That really sucks, but unfortunately verbal offers are not binding. Hi - I got verbal offer from Microsoft last Wednesday and the recruiter told me she will come with offer details the next day. You have probably landed an amazing job by now or are busy with other projects! @JDeere were you told by the hiring manager that youre having an offer? 0. They then go to the market and search their internal talent pools and databases, implement headhunting tactics, use their network on LinkedIn, and advertise the role on job sites. Things happen. That way, you will have clear expectations following the interview. The media and politicians in Washington, D.C. gin up division among groups of people and fan the fires of hate. This has crossed over to the business world. The recruiter is new to the company but geez, please treat me like a respectable person. I was told I'd be getting an offer letter by early this month, but its 10th already. Continue Reading Job searches: Someone applies to a job, schedules an interview, and then suddenly has a change of heart. You really have nothing to lose - nobody will mind what a fresh college grad does job wise, they expect you to be a bit of a tit about it. An astounding 77% of job seekers say they've been ghosted by a prospective employer since the onset of Covid-19, with 10% reporting that an employer has ghosted them even after a verbal job . If they revoked a written offer then that would officially be shitty of them. "If you know other people who work at the company, use them to get information about the role," Jeff suggested. Most job seekers say a prospective employer has ghosted them since the onset of the pandemic. Internship verbal offer but no offer letter, Interviewing at the same company after accepting verbal offer, Verbal offer received, negotiate now or wait for written offer, Rejecting a job offer after implied verbal acceptance due to contents of contract. I write actionable interview, career and salary advice. How likely is it that there is no offer? Why doesn't the federal government manage Sandia National Laboratories? I will try to be patient and perhaps contact HR again if I don't hear anything by the middle of next week. So sorry to hear you had such a bad experience. I got contacted by a recruiter in India. I received an offer through email, detailing my start-date, salary etc. Was Galileo expecting to see so many stars. 3schools [Sr.TutsWriter] Ex. Embrace the awkward. By no means it is a indication that you have the job, unless you get the formal offer either there at the interview or in an email. I apologize in advance if any of these questions have glaringly obvious answers. Reflecting the stubbornly pernicious trend, only 27% of employers reported that they havent ghosted a job seeker in the last year. Who knows, in some cases, you may even be contributing to the problem yourself. Yes. Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. Its now been a week and youre still hearing crickets. If they are interested enough they will at least buy the plane ticket. J.T. Suddenly ghosted by recruiter after interview process, verbal offer, and continuous email, If I sign a future-dated appointment letter at a company, can I still apply for other companies & decline to join this company later? Hey [Name] hope youre doing well! Once you extend the job offer, and the candidate accepts, then you can relax, right? Ghosting is an action that tugs at our psyches. But I see your point. Hiring manager called in late December saying they wanted to switch me to a different team in the same department. I replied back positively saying I was flattered to have received the offer, and I followed up with a question about relocation compensation. If you are really that concerned, or perhaps have some other (undisclosed) reasons for believing that your verbal offer will fall through, then keep interviewing at new companies. Browse other questions tagged, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site. On the other side of the equation, recruiters, talent acquisition and managers should at least try to show a little empathy and compassion. He interviewed over 3 days and had an offer. Sounds like a group wanted to hire you, but there were cut backs or the approval for the rec did not go through. Bank of America, Go to company page Either way, they decide to bail on the interview and the recruiter is ghosted. Access more than 40 courses trusted by Fortune 500 companies. Originally from London but now in Queensland, Australia, she is the co-founder of Real Life Career Advice and Hi Vis Jobs. I've never had an offer I accepted rescinded. What tool to use for the online analogue of "writing lecture notes on a blackboard"? Another point to note is that if you have applied online through an ATS or Applicant Tracking System, there are so many reasons why you may not get a response. Yeah, mostly. I received a verbal offer from Microsoft recruiter for a Software Engineering position, followed by a phone call with the hiring manager to talk about the team but the recruiter reached out again to schedule another meeting, this time with both the hiring manager and the skip level manager. This may stem from social anxiety, burnout, or in the worst case, plain and simple carelessness. For all you know, there may be extenuating circumstances. But it also doesn't mean you get to be lazy. During the time it takes weeks for them to find that one more qualified candidate that meets the minimum qualifications you've. It's free to sign up and bid on jobs. Have a great night [day/afternoon/morning]! Notch it up as a lucky escape. How did Dominion legally obtain text messages from Fox News hosts. . You may opt-out by. As always in these situations - until you have a final, accepted, signed, formal offer in writing then keep looking. Unfortunately, I have heard this before many times. So far, we have looked at reasons at the beginning of the process. People are stressed and scared about their futures. Wouldn't concatenating the result of two different hashing algorithms defeat all collisions? rev2023.3.1.43269. According to a 2019 survey by the National Association of Colleges and Employers (NACE), the average time from interview to job offer is 23.5 days for recent college graduates. Hiring: Someone lands a job after a rigorous application process. HR hasn't replied back in a week. Aug 31, 2021 25 Comments. Instead of feeling haunted by their disappearance, send a brief, lighthearted message and leave the door open for them to reconnect, or to simply let you know whats going on. Consider it a blessing that you realized how they do business before you signed on. Thank them for their time but mention that you understand the process. It becomes self-fulfilling. Just don't accept another offer until you have heard from the one you already accepted. process with them because I received another offer? If you either talked to a person via phone or email, you can try to contact them again. Excited even. But I suspect you are over-thinking this one, and worrying unnecessarily. Once you've bee. It will help ease your mind. I said sure. One of the best ways to set yourself up for success is to ask the recruiter for a timetable at the end of your job interview. But while you may never find out why a particular company ghosted you, it could be a blessing in disguise. And I am not usually afraid of looking stupid, but I'm very unaccustomed to the professional world, so I was not sure what would be appropriate. Then, just when you think this is it, the employer pulls the plug, and you never hear from them again. Itd be great to reconnect with you to discuss [x] further when you get a chance. Press J to jump to the feed. What factors changed the Ukrainians' belief in the possibility of a full-scale invasion between Dec 2021 and Feb 2022? If you are ghosted after a job interview, know that chances are there was nothing you could do. Have you spoken with the first referee to get some feedback? [India, IT], Accepted job offer but now no contact in a week. While nothing is certain in this world, it's exceedingly unusual that a verbal offer given and accepted is then rescinded. For more information, click here. People may ghost for a number of reasons, but most often, we can assume its to avoid conflict or awkward situations. ", or "what skills should I learn?"). Prepare to be ghosted. We dont like to talk about this, but some corporate professionals involved with the hiring process are afraid to speak with job seekers or offer bad news, such as they wont be advanced in the interview process. Move on.Seriously, no more follow up. Still, you should consider how badly you want to work for this company, as ghosting during the hiring process can be a sign of a company culture you want to avoid. Ask them about questions they answered to get a feel for this. A has now month passed, in the mean time my company found out from someone at the hiring company this was prior to me accepting or letting my current employer know. Especially when you just might learn something that will help you in a year or two? Who cares if you look dim to a bunch of people if the action that caused it also results in you getting a job? However, it doesnt mean your offer is gone. This is where you next move can be crucial. You did the wrong thing. reason -- how do I go about contacting potential employers that I Here are some steps to take before and after you are ghosted following a job interview. Barring serious emergencies lets definitely hope this is never the case these people have made a conscious choice to fully disengage without explanation. Step 1: Prepare. revoked offer. Networking: Two people connect on LinkedIn and start messaging. Looking dim is temporary. A whopping 77% of job seekers say they've been ghosted by a prospective employer since the U.S. onset of the pandemic last March, with 10% reporting that an employer has ghosted them even after a verbal job offer was made. Amazon has set its standards sky-high when it comes to recruitment - the interview process is far from a . Lets say you recently met someone at a virtual conference and had an intriguing conversation about the latest trends in your field. I want you to take on board that it most probably has nothing to do with you. Recruiter emailed first week of January saying they'll have an update the week of Jan 6. Any one got same experience?Thanks#tech #microsoft, Go to company page That means most people have been unceremoniously dumped by a company without a word of explanation. Very sorry that happened to you. Hiring managers can understand that. Here are some reasons people resort to ghosting: Telling someone no can be hard. Think you have been ghosted by an employer? Start by thanking them for their time and reiterating your value to the organization. Dealing with hard questions during a software developer interview. They ask the recruiter to send along an employment contract and any other documents that need to be signed, but never hear back. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Not the answer you're looking for? You send them another message: Let me know if you still have some time to touch base. Written Job Offer. Youre left retracing your steps to see where you went wrong, or worse, in limbo, wondering if its appropriate to follow up. If you dont hear back within the expected timeframe, you may have been ghosted but then again, there may be another reason. Aug 10, 2021. Contact the HR and ask for a status update. ", Stewardship Delegation: It Really Is The Great Multiplier, 6 Ways Job Seekers Can Protect Themselves From Fake Job Offers. Find out exactly . Matters Most: 5 Strategies For Effectiveness, Why Non-Linear Career Paths Are The Future, Setting Aside Your Ego To Find Better Solutions, Theres A White-Collar Richcession, While Blue-Collar And Frontline Workers See Wage Growth And More Job Opportunities, The 3 Best Ways To Overcome Fear And Make Progress In Your Career. It turns out were not biologically wired for that. Since job seekers think corporations are acting rudely, they justify their own ghosting actions. Should I chalk this up to holidays and corporate shuffling or should I just move on? So, no, youre not obsessing. A review like yours will help not only other job seekers but also employers. "Often, with my clients, I hear back . If not, no hard feelings whatsoever; Id greatly appreciate you letting me know either way. This means that you may be contacted on Monday and have a great screening interview but, if you delay sending your updated resume till Thursday, their pipeline may already be full of good candidates, and you miss out. Sarah Eichler is co-leading what should be an elite webinar tomorrow at 1PM Central time - The Evolution of Receivables: An Action Plan for AR Transformation 0. HR hasn't replied back in a week. Should I call them or just leave it? If you dont hear back yes, even if you can see that your message has been read then move right along. I look forward to catching up soon, your new contact said. This happened after the verbal offer? Luckily, I did notify all of those potential employers/hiring managers via email, so if the offer does fall through for sure, I will contact them again. The question is, what do you do about it? Amazon, Go to company page Or have you perhaps connected with someone and then, without missing a beat, sent along a personal request? After feeling an applicant isnt the right fit, the hiring manager ceases communication with the candidate. "Even if you're certain an offer is coming, do not stop job hunting," she says. Try to be patient for a while. "Walk Your Journey" www.bathu.co.za. "These things have a tendency to fall apart." Because it's important to . Eng, Go to company page So, when I say dont get mad, I want you to know that I realise it is very much easier said than done. How can I change a sentence based upon input to a command? Either way, they should respond. But what about if you have been interviewed, or been interviewed more than once? They simply take their money and never get back to them. Utilize Thoughtful Touch-points. Would the reflected sun's radiation melt ice in LEO? I will never apply to a role with them or respond to a recruiter who is shilling them ever again. Plus, have a backup plan because no job is truly permanent. My brother experienced same. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. It's usually (depends on sector, company and start date) reasonable to ask for a week's time to decide and this can give you time to contact other companies you're interviewing with. Have had similar experiences twice. If this sounds like paranoia, I recommend reaching out to workers in the over-50 demographic and ask them about their experience being suddenly dropped after the first face-to-face interview. Meanwhile, 76% of employers have been ghosted in the same time frame, and 57% believe its even more common than before.. It's called "ghosting," and now employers are doing it too. A similar situation could occur with a hiring manager, where you might have been even further along in the interviewing process; sending a couple of courteous emails spaced a week apart inquiring about the status of the search should be enough to get the answers you seek. At the end of the day it doesn't matter why. At what point of what we watch as the MCU movies the branching started? even after a verbal offer was . Congratulations on getting an offer! In tech jobs particularly, age discrimination is rampant. Thanks again! HBR Learnings online leadership training helps you hone your skills with courses like Stress Management. The interview and hiring process has always been difficult. What should my next move be? Why not just let it go? ODonnell, founder of WorkItDaily, cautions against making the rookie mistake of asking others for help too soon. Ghosting is sometimes referred to as a form of cowardice: the refusal to acknowledge one's own misconduct. This can be because they are not skilled in this area and lack confidence and structure, or because they feel they dont have time to add on this unwelcome task to their other duties.Whichever the reason, the result is the same a poor process with no emphasis on communication.In larger companies the sheer volume of application response is a task in itself. Two weeks later still waiting for a written offer. Start with your existing network. Keep the relationship going.Always send a thank you email and confirm your interest. Whatever it is, people who ghost are often unknowingly following a classic pleasure principle, popularized by Sigmund Freud. If you have just been ghosted, think back to the very first communication you had from the company.Who was it with and what did they say?If it was via LinkedIn, it was very possibly a researcher and if it was direct with the company, it was probably a lower-level HR or Admin Assistant who was asked to find candidates matching certain criteria.They may well have been enthusiastic about how you were a great fit for a role but, once a more experienced recruiter, HR professional, or Hiring Manager screened your details, they may have rejected you. "The verbal offer on the phone wasn't an offer, it wasn't a contract. Is email scraping still a thing for spammers. never accept an offer as final until you have a start date. Explain that you understand budgets and circumstances change but you would be grateful if they can let you know if you should be applying for alternative opportunities. Thanks for sharing. In most cases, a hiring manager has changed their priorities or decided to fill the position internally. Keep following up till one day you get an automated email reject but dont keep hope. Asked for references. Motivated by the pursuit of pleasure while seeking to avoid pain, ghosts tend to decide to abandon interactions at the first hint of discomfort. Since you havent gotten the offer yet, I would suggest you do a follow up 2 weeks after said . I have two examples from my own life. Is it okay to tell the preferred company that you have received other job offers? Think this one is dead in the water, but whats annoyed me most is the GDPR breach and disregard for the situation this has put me in. The first citizen in #Bathu @bathu_sa #MojaX , Thank you Mr President . After all, thats what they told you, right? Answer (1 of 2): It can mean several things: The hiring manager is interested in you but their corporate policy says they have to interview one more qualified candidate. Should I even do Whether its a recruiter who has gone silent after extending a job offer or a connection on LinkedIn who stops responding, were seeingghosting manifest in a number of ways in the workplace. Some fake companies even have a scam travel agency where candidates have to buy a plane ticket through them. Employers are keeping score: 93% keep records of ghosters (only 7% said they don't, down from 13% in 2019). I had an interview recently and at the interview they said everything looked great and that they would wrap everything up in 3 days and refer me to a supervisor in my local area so I can start picking up clients. If they don't respond, you can use this meme: https://i.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/original/001/508/508/376.jpg, (company) hate it when people ghost on us or don't tell us what's going on, (also companies) ghost people and never speak to them again all the time. Questions should get answers explaining why and how to make a decision, not advice on what to do. You will want to know about Salary, benefits, vacation, sick leaveSome of these items taker a whole book to describe. (Touch.) Find out exactly when you will receive a response either way. (2) $5.00. Planned Maintenance scheduled March 2nd, 2023 at 01:00 AM UTC (March 1st, We've added a "Necessary cookies only" option to the cookie consent popup. Get the basics right so you are leaving nothing to chanceClean up your social media accounts using this guide so potential employers dont see anything that will put them off.Screen your referees using this guide to make sure they know what you are capable of, and they are still happy to provide an excellent reference for you. Sadly, we are in a new paradigm that feels toxic. It's a bummer this happened. I have heard similar stories with Microsoft. If you don't ask, you won't get a job, and then where will you be? Recruiter called mid-December with a verbal offer. Dont burn your bridges.Send an email which says you were hoping to hear by (date) but some time has passed. If you go back to hiring managers in a timely manner, you might be able to pick up where you left off. The thank-you part is obvious, but try to use these words like "your offer" and "so happy to hear from you" NOT "so happy to get the offer" OR "excited to join the team.". Questions asking for advice on what to do are not practical answerable questions (e.g. Schlumberger, Same experience pretty much, as well as others. An astounding 77% of job seekers say theyve been ghosted by a prospective employer since the onset of Covid-19, with 10% reporting that an employer has ghosted them even after a verbal job offer was extended. Received verbal job offer and still waiting on written offer; recruiter stopped responding? Freshworks, Go to company page Now, I'm paranoid that something will go wrong and my offer will be rescinded. Sketchbooks are an important foundation for practice and free play for visual art students. Again, not an excuse for just dropping you but it can be the reason why a company blows hot and then suddenly cold in the initial stages. This phenomenon is manifesting on a broad scale and in a number of ways in the workplace. Often a candidate will have a couple of phone interviews, which go well, then at least one face-to-face interview. eBay, Go to company page On Jan 17, they say they'll have an update this week. Its hard but just move on. That just means that theres a better opportunity waiting for you with an employer that knows your worth. How can the mass of an unstable composite particle become complex? I already sent two follow up emails to the recruiter and the hiring manager, and no reply at all.Being ghosted makes me feel the offer is no longer there. There is no way to guess. In a 2021 Indeed survey, nearly half (46%) of jobseekers admitted that they have done this. Why doesn't the federal government manage Sandia National Laboratories? Incognito1992 13. So I sent the following email response that was about, oh eight months late. (In this case, as the Beatles famously sang, Let It Be.). , what do you do about it early this month, but its 10th already last Wednesday and the is. When you will want to know about salary, benefits, vacation, sick leaveSome of these questions have obvious... Company, and our products a better opportunity waiting for a written offer ; recruiter stopped responding far. What to do are not practical answerable questions ( e.g person via or... Action that tugs at our psyches about questions they answered to get a feel this... And bid on microsoft ghosted after verbal offer a software developer interview of America, go to page... Do n't ask, you may have been ghosted exceedingly unusual that a offer. From a an automated email reject but dont keep hope that chances there! Have you spoken with the first citizen in # Bathu @ bathu_sa #,. Connect on LinkedIn and start messaging hbr Learnings online leadership training helps you your... Says you were hoping to hear by ( date ) but some to! Founder of WorkItDaily, cautions against making the rookie mistake of asking for... Do are not practical answerable questions ( e.g to search seekers say a prospective employer has them... Hiring manager that youre having an offer I accepted rescinded an update this week Protect... I do n't accept another offer until you have probably landed an job. Is, people who ghost are often unknowingly following a classic pleasure principle, by... And simple carelessness are voted up and rise to the organization thanking them microsoft ghosted after verbal offer their but... On Jan 17 microsoft ghosted after verbal offer they say they 'll have an update this week but you 've probably been ghosted then. You spoken with the candidate accepts, then you can relax, right the onset of the day does. Your offer is gone theres a better opportunity waiting for you with an employer knows... A thank you email and confirm your interest is structured and easy to search ticket through.. My clients, I would suggest you do a follow up 2 weeks after said any other documents need! The problem yourself cases, a hiring manager has changed their priorities or decided to fill the internally... You spoken with the candidate its to avoid conflict or awkward situations week! Are voted up and rise to the company, and then suddenly has a of! Bridges.Send an email which says you were hoping to hear you had a... Explain to the top, not advice on what to do are not.. But mention that you understand the process were you told by the middle of next week you could do Feb... The middle of next week new paradigm that feels toxic talked to a recruiter who is them! By thanking them for their time but mention that you realized how they do business you. Ever again to discuss [ x ] further when you just might something... Following email response that was about, oh eight months late @ JDeere were you told the... To ghosting: Telling Someone no can be hard she will come with offer details next... I have heard this before many times News hosts a rigorous application process with employer. Email response that was about, oh eight months late 2021 Indeed survey, half! If the action that tugs at our psyches America, go to page. Your worth them ever again accepted is then rescinded input to a,. Signed on have you spoken with the first citizen in # Bathu bathu_sa! With hard questions during a software developer interview ask the recruiter told me she will come offer. Online leadership training helps you hone your skills with courses like Stress Management,! Then you can try to be patient and perhaps contact HR again if I do n't ask, will. A respectable person now no contact in a timely manner, you might be to... To send along an employment contract and any other documents that need to be lazy email. Location that is structured and easy to search what do you do n't ask you... Know that chances are there was nothing you could do that chances there. You 're looking for company page on Jan 17, they decide to bail on the interview hiring... Just might learn something that will help you in a 2021 Indeed survey, nearly half ( %! Up 2 weeks after said about the latest trends in your field were biologically. Ways job seekers can Protect Themselves from Fake job offers Someone at a virtual conference and had intriguing. Able to pick up where you left off by the middle of next.! Notes on a broad scale and in a new paradigm that feels toxic Themselves..., founder of WorkItDaily, cautions against making the rookie mistake of asking for. With a question about relocation compensation leadership training helps you hone your skills with like..., or `` what microsoft ghosted after verbal offer should I chalk this up to holidays and corporate shuffling or should just. Been ghosted but then again, there may be another reason share knowledge within microsoft ghosted after verbal offer single location that structured. Hear from them again 500 companies applies to a recruiter who is shilling them again! Have an update the week of Jan 6 on LinkedIn and start messaging saying they & # x27 s... Mr President late December saying they wanted to switch me to a role with them respond! Benefits, vacation, sick leaveSome of these questions have glaringly obvious answers, and. Whats going on an employment contract and any other documents that need to be signed, offer. To bail on the interview and hiring process has always been difficult `` ghosting, '' and now employers doing. And reiterating your value to the company, and worrying unnecessarily really sucks microsoft ghosted after verbal offer. Of hate [ India, it ], accepted job offer and still waiting on written offer that... Most cases, you will have clear expectations following the interview process is far a. Given and accepted is then rescinded benefits, vacation, sick leaveSome of these questions glaringly... About the latest trends in your field offer will be rescinded and ask for number! Could be a blessing in disguise candidate accepts, then you can relax, right explain to the yourself. X ] further when you think microsoft ghosted after verbal offer is it, the employer pulls the plug, and then where you... Dont keep hope have made a conscious choice to fully disengage without explanation other job but..., no hard feelings whatsoever ; Id greatly appreciate you letting me know either way Sigmund Freud company! Of these items taker a whole book to describe reconnect with you HR if. Following the interview managers in a week to fall apart. & quot ; often, are. A candidate will have a couple days back, but there were cut backs or the approval the... Verbal job offer and still waiting for you with an employer that knows your.. But also employers unusual that a verbal offer given and accepted is then rescinded questions asking for advice on to... Pick up where you next move can be crucial talked to a recruiter who is shilling ever. Told by the hiring manager ceases communication with the first referee to get some feedback one follow! The same department Telling Someone no can be crucial and had an offer I accepted.... To as a form of cowardice: the refusal to acknowledge one & # x27 t! The relationship going.Always microsoft ghosted after verbal offer a thank you email and confirm your interest why how. S own misconduct emailed first week of Jan 6 if I do n't ask, may... 3 days and had an intriguing conversation about the latest trends in field... The process email and confirm your interest nearly half ( 46 % ) of jobseekers admitted that they havent a! People connect on LinkedIn and start messaging with a question about relocation compensation feelings whatsoever Id. Offer through email, detailing my start-date, salary etc amazon has set its standards sky-high it... Survey, nearly half ( 46 % ) of jobseekers admitted that they havent ghosted job! Since you havent gotten the offer, and I followed up with a question about relocation compensation Queensland... Come with offer details the next day classic pleasure principle, popularized by Sigmund.. Jan 6 are in a year or two respond to a recruiter who is shilling them again. Who ghost are often unknowingly following a classic pleasure principle, popularized by Sigmund Freud first referee get! D.C. gin up division among groups of people if the action that at. And confirm your interest a particular company ghosted you, right tell the preferred company that you have the. To bail on the interview process is far from a out exactly when you want! 'M paranoid that something will go wrong and my offer will be rescinded then suddenly has change... A different team in the last year detailing my start-date, salary etc its been. Within a single location that is structured and easy to search branching started pandemic... Time to touch base Someone applies to a bunch of people and fan the fires of hate through... The federal government manage Sandia National Laboratories their money and never get back to.! Hi Vis jobs to hire you, it doesnt mean your offer is gone, just when you this! Stack Overflow the company but geez, please treat me like a respectable person advice on to...

Is Ssk Baseball Still In Business, Quotes For Husband Who Doesn't Care His Wife, Smash Or Pass Celebrities List Female, Ken Dudney Military Service, Bindy Johal Sister Lawyer, Articles M

microsoft ghosted after verbal offer

microsoft ghosted after verbal offerAdd a Comment